Key Points
-
Understanding proofing vs. generalizing in dog training is essential for adequately training your dog.
-
Dogs naturally find it difficult to generalize their behaviors, so proofing is essential.
-
Educating on proofing vs. generalizing in dog training combines the two teachings to solidify your dog's new behaviors.
Training your dog is both a challenging and rewarding experience. While certain breeds are better at learning training commands than others, effective training takes time and proper education. Two primary forms of dog training are proofing and generalizing. Understanding proofing vs. generalizing in dog training educates you on training your dog, ensuring they learn a command or behavior and that the training remains consistent regardless of external circumstances.
The key difference between proofing vs. generalizing in dog training is their role in your teaching efforts. Generalizing teaches your dog commands and behavior patterns, such as sit, stop, or lie down, while proofing teaches your dog how to maintain their training, regardless of their external circumstances.
Proofing Vs. Generalizing
Teaching your dog to sit is a form of generalization training. Complete this training in your home where your dog is comfortable and familiar. Once they understand your command and begin learning these new behaviors, it's easier for them to follow your lead in other environments. Solidifying their training requires more than generalizing; this is where proofing comes in.
Proofing is training your dog to repeat generalized behaviors, such as sitting, in new environments. Proofing is practiced gradually in places that increase their levels of distractibility as your dog conquers the behavior in each. For example, once your dog learns to sit at home, you might take them to a friend's house to practice next.
Training a dog takes time and is best done as soon as you acquire your pup. Dog Trainer, Lynda Lobo, talks about the importance of training your dog young.
"Training your dog should start as soon as you get her. If you get a puppy, don’t wait too long to start training because socialization is crucial to a puppy. Basic obedience is a great way to start out training a puppy, but you need to manage expectations because a puppy won’t be able to work as long or as hard and won’t have the focus of an older dog."
What Is Generalization?
Generalization is your dog's ability to exhibit training behaviors anywhere they go. When your dog is young, generalization should be the first step in their training.
Teaching your dog how to walk on a leash is an example of generalization training. As you teach your dog, they learn how to walk on a leash throughout your neighborhood or trail, and this area is where you teach them routinely. After a while, your dog becomes comfortable walking their usual route and exhibits proper behavior.
Once they learn this training, taking them on a new route will be much more manageable than initially. This doesn't mean you don't experience issues when walking your dog on a new route, but their learned behaviors allow for a much smoother process.
Other examples of generalization training are potty training. Most dogs are excellent adopters of potty training, preferring to handle their business outside.
Generalization in dog training is your dog's basic need to learn new behaviors, but you must combine generalization with other training methods to maintain these behaviors in new environments.
Why Is Generalization Important in Dog Training?
Generalization is vital for initially teaching your dog new behaviors. The problem with generalization is that dogs need help generalizing behaviors in new environments.
Proofing allows them to stay consistent in new environments. Still, taking the necessary time to teach generalization training in the first place is necessary for your dog to understand commands and proper behavior.
Have you ever brought your dog to the dog park for the first time or out in public, and all of their training seems to go out the window? This is because while you've taught them "general" commands, they haven't "proofed" them. Proofing teaches your dog how to follow learned commands in new or distracting environments, like public places or around other animals.
The Four D's in Generalization Training
In dog training, there are four D's for you to use to train your dog correctly via generalization: distance, distraction, duration, and difficulty.
Distance
It's important to be mindful of increasing the distance between you and your dog while teaching them new behaviors. At first, keep a short distance between you and your canine to maintain their focus.
When your training efforts are successful, add half a foot to the distance between you. Continue doing this as long as your dog progresses in their training. If you add distance and lose their focus, shorten the length by a foot and continue training until they are successful again.
Distraction
In the beginning stages of dog training, it's important not to have any distractions. Your dog needs to be able to focus on understanding your commands and what you're asking of them.
After a few training sessions, adding a level of distraction strengthens your dog's training. Only administer controlled distractions, such as having another person or pet in the room while training your pup.
Uncontrolled distractions, like a dog park or at a large gathering, are too stimulating for your dog and result in improper training. Being able to follow commands and exhibit proper behavior even in the presence of distractions is a sign of a well-trained dog.
Duration
The duration that your dog maintains a specific behavior is also essential. When preparing their meals, untrained dogs jump, whine, and beg for food until it's given to them.
Training your dog to sit and be still for the duration it takes you to prepare their food is one example of generalization training. At first, your dog doesn't want to sit still and wait for their food, but with practice, your training efforts teach them to remain patient and obedient.
Start small, and don't expect miracles initially. Set the duration for a few seconds, working your way up to a few minutes. Your dog finds it easy to maintain their training behaviors while following your commands as training progresses.
Difficulty
In general, dog training difficulty refers to the circumstances you train your dog in. Your dog's difficulty depends on their current training and individual personality.
If your dog gets easily distracted by having another pet around, training them in the presence of another pet is more complicated. Still, with prolonged exposure, your dog adapts and blocks out distractions.
Only start upping the difficulty of your dog's training if they pass the other "D's" because they are necessary for learning commands regardless of the difficulty level.
What Is Proofing?
Proofing is similar to generalization, except it's only necessary if your dog isn't maintaining their training behaviors in new environments. Your dog has proper training while at home or playing in the yard but has difficulty when out in public.
It's crucial to introduce your dog to different environments and socialize with them to understand where their weak spots are. If your dog has proper training for playing with other dogs that you introduce them to individually, the best test to ensure the training is consistent is to take them to the dog park.
Being around new dogs in a busy environment challenges their training and allows them to learn more effectively. This is where proofing is helpful to solidify the results your dog already has in specific environments to ensure they remain obedient in all settings.
Proofing only comes after your dog receives proper training. Throwing them into hectic or stressful environments too quickly halts their progress.
Why Is Proofing Important in Dog Training?
Proofing is essential for teaching your dog how to remain obedient even in new surroundings. Dogs don't naturally have generalized behavior. They are reactive and, without proper training, have difficulty exhibiting restraint or obedience.
Proofing teaches your dog to maintain restraint and stay obedient by learning your expectations of them in various places and situations.
When training at home, they only associate their teachings with the environment you're training them in. When you place them in new environments, they need help maintaining their learned training if you slowly introduce them into these environments while proofing their previous training.
Which Dog Training Method Is Most Effective?
Generalizing and proofing go hand in hand, so there isn't one more effective method. Think of these training types as two steps in the same process.
Generalizing comes first, as it teaches your dog proper behaviors and commands. Proofing comes second, as it teaches your dog to maintain these behaviors and commands regardless of their external surroundings.
If you implement both, your dog's training is effective, and you experience issues in their obedience.
What Are the Three Main Methods of Dog Training?
There are three main methods for training your dog. These methods include dominance theory, positive reinforcement, and the scientific approach.
Dominance Theory
Dominance theory suggests that dogs are pack animals that have a leader who dictates the structure and behavior of the rest of the pack. The leader is the most dominant of the canines, and once they establish this dominance, the pack leader receives the respect of the rest of the dogs.
Using dominance while training your dog is a way for them to gain your respect and allow you to shift their behavior. Many methods for establishing dominance include using correction tools, such as a dog whistle or a training collar. Physically disciplining is also a form of dominance training, but not a healthy or humane way to train your pet.
Dominance training is likely only needed during generalization training to establish a dynamic between you and your pup. After that, other forms of training are more effective when proofing.
Positive Reinforcement
Using positive reinforcement is an excellent tool for training your dog.
Positive reinforcement rewards your dog for following commands or behaving appropriately during training. When your dog isn't following your instructions or refuses to listen, you don't reward them.
Your dog associates rewards with the behaviors you teach them, and eventually, these behaviors become dominant as they constantly strive to receive rewards from you.
Positive reinforcement is an excellent training method for both generalization training and proofing. Your pet must know when they're behaving properly in familiar and unfamiliar environments.
Scientific Approach
The scientific approach in dog training is the best method for training your pup.
With this method, you assess your dog's behavior and personality traits to train them accordingly. The scientific approach focuses on teaching your pet based on their abilities without pushing them past their limits.
This training method is less stressful for your pup and doesn't require you to put them through training that causes too much stress or physical exertion.
Use the scientific approach alongside other training methods. If you choose to use dominance training, don't push your pet past their limits, and take their age, breed, and health into consideration.
For positive reinforcement, use a scientific approach by rewarding them for behaviors that are difficult for their breed or when they excel at overcoming their individual behavior obstacles.
Consider the scientific approach while generalizing and proofing your dog's behaviors. It allows you to give them the time and space needed to learn a new behavior while using methods specific to their needs.
Don't Forget To Have Fun
Training your dog doesn't have to be stressful or mundane. Get creative in your training sessions to keep you and your canine on track. Turn on fun music in the background while you train, or create a game out of the experience.
When you reward your dog, reward yourself with a snack. Allow your dog to learn at their own pace while taking breaks when necessary. By taking your time, you're releasing some of the stress that comes with training while also creating a safe and comfortable environment for them to learn in.
Research training methods online, and choose ones that fit within your dog's abilities.
Whether you're training a puppy or an adult dog, implementing generalizing and proofing into their training routine is the best way to ensure they remain well-behaved no matter where you take them.
Don't rush the process, and allow your pup to make mistakes. Dogs are great communicators, but that doesn't mean learning new tricks isn't a challenge. Give them enough compassion, time, and understanding to adopt their new behaviors, allowing your dog to become the best version of themselves for you.
If you enjoy reading this article and want more canine-related content, subscribe to BarkSpot to stay updated on new releases!
