5 Dog Insurance Providers: Comparing Coverage and Costs

Key Points

• Embrace Pet Insurance has deductibles ranging from $200-1,000, with reimbursement rates ranging from 70-90 percent. 

• Healthy Paws offers annual deductibles ranging from $100-500, with 60-90 percent reimbursement rates.

• Nationwide has deductibles from $0-1,000, with reimbursement rates varying between 70-100 percent. 

• Pets Best offers deductible options from $50-1,000, with a 70-90 percent reimbursement rate.

• Trupanion has customizable deductibles from $0-1,000, with a reimbursement rate set at 90 percent. 

As a responsible and loving pet owner, you understand the importance of securing pet health insurance for your furry companion. Your dog must receive proper care in case of accidents or illness, and choosing the best insurance provider for your pet is quite challenging.

This article thoroughly analyzes five reputable dog insurance providers, highlighting their coverage options, costs, and customer satisfaction. By the end of this article, you can select the best dog insurance plan for your beloved pet.

Top Rated Pet Health Insurance

by Embrace Pet Insurance

Learn More

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Embrace Pet Insurance

Customers of Embrace Pet Insurance appreciate the company's transparency, ease of claims submission, and fast reimbursement process. The excellent customer service, customizable plans, and the Wellness Rewards program have earned Embrace solid ratings across various review platforms. Some pet owners have experienced premium hikes as their pets age, which may be worth considering when looking at Embrace as your provider.

Embrace Pet Insurance provides comprehensive coverage for your dog, including accidents, illnesses, genetic conditions, chronic conditions, and more. Their customizable policies allow you to choose the reimbursement percentage, annual limit, and deductible that best suits your budget. One notable feature is their Wellness Rewards program, which annually reimburses routine and preventive care services such as vaccinations, dental care, and wellness exams.

Embrace allows you to choose deductibles ranging from $200-1,000, with annual coverage limits between $5,000-30,000. The premiums vary depending on the plan, breed, age, and location of your dog. Additionally, Embrace offers a multi-pet and military discount and a diminishing deductible feature that lowers your annual deductible by $50 for each year you don't receive a claim reimbursement.

Healthy Paws

Healthy Paws has earned a strong reputation for its outstanding customer support, fast and straightforward claims process, and comprehensive coverage. The unlimited benefits have also garnered positive customer feedback, ensuring their pets are safe no matter the cost. Some customers have noted that the lack of preventive care coverage is a drawback. Still, overall, the provider maintains high satisfaction ratings among pet owners.

Healthy Paws offers extensive coverage for your dog's accidents and illnesses, including congenital conditions, diagnostic tests, medications, and more. Healthy Paws stands out for its unlimited lifetime coverage with no annual, per-incident, or lifetime caps. The provider doesn't cover pre-existing conditions, exam fees, or preventive care services such as vaccinations and dental cleanings.

With Healthy Paws, you opt for annual deductibles ranging from $100-500 and reimbursement percentages between 60-90 percent. Your dog's breed, age, and location determine the cost of the premium. There are no multi-pet or military discounts so the pricing may be higher than other providers. However, the unlimited benefits make Healthy Paws an attractive choice for pet owners concerned about potential high medical costs.

Nationwide

While Nationwide's coverage options are extensive, customer reviews are mixed. Many customers appreciate the various plan options, the multi-pet discount, and the comprehensive Whole Pet with Wellness plan. Some individuals have expressed dissatisfaction with the claims process and the restrictions on pre-existing conditions. As with any provider, it's crucial to carefully review the policy and analyze the coverage limitations before committing.

Nationwide provides three different plans for dog owners: Major Medical, Whole Pet with Wellness, and Medical. The Major Medical plan covers accidents and illnesses. In contrast, the Whole Pet with Wellness plan is a comprehensive option that includes preventive care, diagnostics, and treatments.

The Medical plan covers common accidents and procedures, making it a more budget-friendly choice for pet owners seeking basic coverage. All Nationwide plans cover hereditary and congenital conditions, dental illnesses, and prescription medications.

With Nationwide, deductibles range from $0-1,000, depending on your chosen plan. The reimbursement percentage varies between 70-100 percent. Your dog's breed, age, and location can influence premium prices. Nationwide offers multi-pet discounts, which reduce the cost of insuring multiple pets.

Pets Best

The positive reviews acquired by Pets Best rave about its customizable plans, the option to add wellness coverage, and the lack of age limits for enrollment. Customers appreciate the straightforward claims process and quick reimbursements. However, some pet owners have reported premium increases over time. Evaluate the provider's policy details carefully to ensure they meet your dog's needs.

Pets Best offers two main coverage options for your dog: Essential and Elite. Their Essential plan covers accidents, illnesses, and hereditary conditions. The Elite plan provides additional rehabilitation, acupuncture, and chiropractic care coverage. Pets Best also offers a Wellness plan as an add-on to cover routine and preventive care services. Notably, Pets Best doesn't have age limits for enrollment, making it an excellent option for older dogs.

Pets Best provides a range of deductible options from $50-1,000, with annual coverage limits between $5,000 and unlimited, depending on your chosen plan. The reimbursement percentages range from 70-90 percent. Pets Best offers a multi-pet discount, lowering costs if you have several pets to insure.

Trupanion

Pet owners praise Trupanion for its comprehensive coverage, 90 percent reimbursement rate, and excellent customer support. The absence of payout limits per condition has been a significant selling point for many customers. On the other hand, the lack of preventive care coverage and discounts may be drawbacks for some pet owners. 

Trupanion is well-known for providing extensive coverage for accidents and illnesses with no payout limits per condition, including hereditary and congenital diseases, dental illnesses, and alternative therapies. The provider also offers an optional add-on called Pet Owner Assistance for non-medical situations, such as boarding fees and trip cancellations. Unfortunately, Trupanion doesn't cover routine or preventive care, exam fees, or pre-existing conditions.

Trupanion offers customizable deductibles ranging from $0-1,000, with reimbursement percentages set at 90 percent. The absence of payout limits per condition is a significant advantage, providing peace of mind that your dog has coverage regardless of the cost. Trupanion doesn't currently offer any multi-pet or military discounts.

What To Look For in Pet Insurance

Take the time to look at every dog insurance provider's plan and analyze everything. On the one hand, you make monthly payments to that company, and you must know whether the insurance kicks in in case something goes wrong with your dog's health. 

On the other, depending on the condition and the type of emergency, a veterinary bill may cost you thousands of dollars. If you don't get insurance and have some money saved for these events, you risk going into debt. Regrettably, insurance doesn't always cover all ailments. 

Hip dysplasia is an excellent example of an exclusion that most companies use, as the surgery costs between $7,000-12,000 if it's for both hips. Miami-based Dr. Patty Khuly, VMD MBA, states that "[t]he particular veterinary hospital's costs, its geographic location, and the quality of the surgeon may well dictate an even higher price. That's why board-certified surgeons will almost inevitably provide higher-end estimates for hip dysplasia treatment."

The coverage of any pet insurance plan is the first aspect you should consider when deciding. Most basic plans offer protection against emergencies, such as accidents or sudden illnesses stemming from conditions your dog isn't known to suffer from. 

However, the coverage splits into three main categories — for accidents and sudden illnesses, exclusively accidents, and plans that include wellness services, such as vaccinations, deworming, and even grooming in some cases.  

Conditions Not Covered

Most dog insurance companies don't cover animals against conditions such as dental disease, hip dysplasia, elbow dysplasia, or any hereditary conditions your pet might develop during their lifetime, pregnancy, and birth, as well as death and pet theft. 

Depending on your chosen provider, preventive care is often excluded from the plan. Two other exclusions are behavior problems and elective procedures, i.e., procedures that don't extend your dog's life. 

Reimbursement System

The way pet insurance works is unique in the sense that your vet requires you to pay for the bill. Afterward, the insurance company reimburses you. The reimbursement rate ranges from 70-90 percent of the total bill value, with you being responsible for the rest of the cost. 

The higher the amount you're paying for your pet insurance every month, the higher the percentage you should expect reimbursement. A limited number of covered claims exist for your dog's insurance every year, so if you go above that, you have to foot the bill entirely. 

Waiting Periods

Before selecting a pet insurance provider, you must become as informed about it as possible. This also involves looking at how you submit a claim in case of an accident or illness. How easy is the brand to reach out to? Do you have to call and talk to someone, or can you rely on a mobile app to scan your vet's bill and send it to the company? 

You need to know the answers to these questions before spending your hard-earned cash on pet insurance that might be useless and result in you getting in debt to keep your pet healthy. The reimbursement policy and how long it takes to get your money back are two other crucial aspects when deciding between one company and the other. If it takes you two to three months to get paid, you should go with another provider, which pays you in just 15 days or less. 

Comparing Quotes 

As you're likely to know if you've done some research on the top dog insurance providers in the United States, the cost of the plans tends to vary a lot and might also not be transparent. The companies' websites should specify the prices, but that is rarely the case. 

The cost varies depending on your dog's breed, age, previous coverage, or chronic diseases. But the only way to know how much you should expect to pay is to call the brand or fill out a form with your dog's information to get an estimate of monthly payments. Generally, expect to pay between $25-40 or more for dogs or cats. Cats tend to be more affordable insurance-wise. 

Also, look at the availability of your pet insurance plan. If the company doesn't offer services in your state, you might as well not waste time researching it. If you travel with your pet regularly, if you have an idea of the states in which you may seek out veterinary assistance, consider all those locations when selecting a plan. 

Which Dog Insurance Provider Is Right for You?

When comparing the five featured dog insurance providers, you should use several key factors to determine the best fit for your pet's needs and budget. All providers offer customizable plans, but each has specific benefits and drawbacks. Embrace's Wellness Rewards program stands out for routine and preventive care, while Healthy Paws' unlimited benefits appeal to those concerned about high medical costs.

Nationwide's range of plan options cater to various budgets, Pets Best's lack of age limits is valuable for older dogs, and Trupanion's no payout limits per condition provide peace of mind for expensive treatments.

It's essential to evaluate coverage options and pricing and each provider's customer satisfaction and overall reputation in the industry. Thoroughly reviewing their plans and understanding the specific terms and conditions allows you to decide on the best dog insurance provider for your family.

Pet Insurance Protects You and Your Pet

An August 2023 article by MarketWatch suggests that close to 35 percent of pet owners still don't know much about dog insurance, which is why they don't get any pet coverage. Be the exception — for your dog's and your family's well-being in the long run. Is the time right for you?

Researching and choosing the best insurance plan for your dog demonstrates your dedication to their health and well-being. While you hope never to need it, having an insurance plan gives you peace of mind, knowing that you can handle any unexpected medical expenses. Protect your pet by finding the dog insurance provider that best meets your needs, and focus on enjoying a healthy and happy life together.

If you enjoyed this article and learned something new, share it with your friends and subscribe to Bark Spot today!